Top 5 Best Tequila Brands | EdNews' Consensus List

Whether you're raising a glass to a special occasion or just enjoying a quiet evening, the right tequila can turn any moment into something memorable. But with so many options out there, how do you find the perfect bottle? Don't worry, tequila lovers! We've done the tasting for you and rounded up the best tequilas around. From smooth reposados to bold añejos, these picks are sure to impress both newbies and seasoned sippers. So, grab a glass, slice up some lime, and let's dive into the world of top-notch tequila. Cheers to finding your new favorite!

As all tequilas are not created equal, when looking for the best tequilas you want to focus on agave content, flavor profile, and how they’re produced. EdNews visited 10 leading expert websites to see which tequilas were rated the highest. Our list is ranked based on the most-recommended tequilas across these sites. Salud!

The List

1. Fortaleza Blanco

Produced in the heart of Tequila, Mexico, Fortaleza Blanco Tequila packs a quality punch with notes of citrus, olives, and black pepper. Insider says agave experts consider Fortaleza one of the most revered brands in the world of tequila. This all comes down to their reputation that has been built up since 2005. But its roots dig deeper, with lineage tracing back all the way to Don Cernobio, the first to export tequila to the U.S., Insider adds. Plus, their value of tradition flows strong in each bottle. They have been utilizing practices like open-air fermentation and stone rolling with a tehona since the beginning. 

The Fortaleza Blanco is also extra-proof with 40 percent ABV, making it a great pick for any celebration. Rolling Stone describes it as more complex than competitors. They also are impressed by the hand-blown, hand-painted glass bottle. 

2. Don Julio 1942

If you enjoy a side of luxury with your tequila on the rocks, Don Julio 1942 is known as one of the most highly rated tequilas on the scene. You may recognize this bottle popping up on celebrity social media stories on nights out. How is it made? It rests for two and a half years in American white-oak barrels. The agave used for production is cooked in a brick oven, roller-milled, and distilled with deep, mineral well water in a stainless steel pot with a copper coil. Liquor says that the mixture of tradition and modern gear makes for a smooth, flowery potion with notes of caramel, vanilla, salt, and spice.

While Don Julio is a hugely successful tequila company, the company is also commended for its charitable efforts, with The Don Julio Fund pledging $1 million to help local communities in Mexico. Why is it called 1942? Tasting Table explains that that is the year that founder Don Julio González started making his spirits. They say to expect sweet vanilla flavors with a touch of oakiness.

3. Casamigos Blanco

You may be skeptical of celebrity-founded tequila, is it really worth the hype? Whether you’re a fan of actor and co-founder George Clooney or not, tequila aficionados say Casamigos is a safe bet. Every batch is distilled for at least two months in stainless steel barrels and is made in the Jalisco highlands from 100 percent agave.

Rolling Stone describes it as smooth and natural tasting. They say to expect sweet agave, ight citrus, and just a touch of vanilla flavor. Due to its smooth and approachable flavor, Casamigos makes for a great tequila to buy if you’re just getting into drinking the spirit.

According to Delish, this bottle is classy without being a try-hard. They love its long, smooth finish.

4. Tequila Ocho Plata

If you’re looking for an agave-centric tequila that shines through in margaritas but doesn’t overpower, Tequila Ocho Plata is a top choice. “As the winner of the Best of Class Silver/Gold (unaged) Tequila award, Ocho Plata bested 110 other tequilas to take home. Developed by third-generation tequilero Carlos Camarena and industry legend Tomas Estes, this tequila is made from premium overripe agaves in Jalisco, Mexico. Complex with a hint of its home terroir, it exhibits both mineral and fruit flavors,” says Forbes.

The spirit is full and complex with notes of grass and earthiness. GQ says this is a bartender favorite for making margaritas. They commend them for being the first brand to be transparent with the year of production and the field the agave was taken from.

5. Herradura Silver

Herradura Silver is ranked as the best overall tequila according to Delish. They say it “packs a punch” with vanilla, citrus, and distinct sweet agave flavors. Apparently, the longer you leave it sitting out, the better it tastes.

“This tequila has one of the bolder flavor profiles you will find, yet it retains the smoothness that defines great tequilas,” writes The Spruce Eats says this bottle has a bolder flavor profile than competitors. That means it won't get lost in cocktails. That being said, it is also not cringe-worthy in shot form either, they write.

GQ adds a bit about the production process behind this bottle: “Herradura Blanco tequila is barrel-aged for 45 days—which goes beyond the industry standard for blanco tequilas—giving subtle oak and vanilla notes, which mesh well with Cointreau or agave syrup.”

Sources used to find these consensus picks

• Forbes
• Food Network
• The Spruce Eats
• Delish
• Tasting Table
• GQ
• Insider
• Wine Mag
• Rolling Stone
• Liquor

Note: This article was not paid for nor sponsored. EdNews is not connected to nor partnered with any of the brands mentioned and receives no compensation for its recommendations. This article may contain affiliate links in which we receive a commission if you make a purchase.