Mel Gibson Movies: 5 Films Most Recommended By Critics

Forget “Mad Max” fury and “Lethal Weapon” explosions for a second. Mel Gibson's career is a wild ride that goes way beyond action flicks. We're talking Shakespearean soliloquies delivered in a kilt (“Braveheart”), Oscar-winning directing chops (“Hacksaw Ridge”), and even a descent into the dark underbelly of Hollywood (“The Beaver”). With a filmography that's as diverse as it is intense, choosing the perfect Mel Gibson movie can feel like deciphering a Gibson code (too soon?). But fret no more cinephiles! This guide will crack the case, decoding the best of Mel, from hidden gems to classics you can't miss. So, put down your medieval weaponry (or at least that old “Lethal Weapon” box set) and get ready to delve into the wild world of Mel Gibson movies. We have created this list of the five best Mel Gibson movies to ever hit the silver screen. We compile our lists by combing through existing consumer rankings and weeding out the consensus recommendations. Don’t happen to see your favorite movie? Don’t worry, tell us about it in a comment and share why you believe it should be on our list!

The List: Best Mel Gibson Movies, According to Fans

1. “Braveheart” (2011)

“Braveheart” will forever go down in history as one of the best Mel Gibson movies. With authentic portrayals that transcend the sands of time, this movie cemented Gibson’s on-screen presence as a legend. Like Wealth of Geeks writes, “Braveheart is a gripping tale of one man's fight for freedom against overwhelming odds.” Also directed by Mel Gibson, this “1995 epic historical drama follows the story of William Wallace in the late 13th century.” Portrayed by Mel, he “leads the Scots in the First War of Scottish Independence against King Edward I of England.”

Breathtaking landscapes and stunning cinematography enhance the narrative, authenticity, and historical accuracy of “Braveheart.” Winner of five Academy Awards, Gibson transports people back in time to a defining chapter in Scottish history. As Ninja Selection depicts, “Braveheart is a movie that shows how Wallace rallies amateur fighters and sets out on a mission to drive the English army led by Edward I out of Scotland.” Under the leadership of Gibson who portrays William Wallace, “the warriors are strong, motivated, and ready to shed blood at Wallace’s call to reclaim their freedom.” In the end, “the road to liberty is not easy, and it demands bloodshed.”

Braveheart showcased Mel Gibson’s genius as a creative force. For these reasons, its legacy endures subsequent generations of audiences and filmmakers alike. As Gold Derby puts it, “Braveheart is Gibson’s most honored film and it recounts the life of William Wallace” and “how he led a Scottish rebellion against England’s tyranny.” Overall, “it was Gibson’s assuredness both in his direction of the action and character scenes that truly caught critics by surprise.” 

2. “The Patriot” (2000)

This film is a riveting historical drama that is by far one of the best Mel Gibson movies. Released in 2000, “The Patriot” explores themes of sacrifice, freedom, and the human spirit. As Movie Web says, “Gibson delivers a memorable performance while the film illuminates us to the tragic effects of war.” For context, “The Patriot follows the story of the peaceful farmer Benjamin Martin, played by Mel Gibson, who is reluctant to join the American Revolution but is forced to do so for revenge.”

Stepping into the shoes of Benjamin Martin is no small feat but Gibson does it beautifully. His legendary performance of a man torn between protecting his family and fighting for a cause greater than himself leads to exponential character development that has you rooting for him from start to finish. As Buddy TV claims, “The Patriot is a commercial and critical success with meticulous attention to detail.” Praised for its accurate depiction of the Revolutionary War, the film has a “real sense of authenticity and depth to the story, making it a truly immersive viewing experience.” In terms of its impact on Gibson’s career, “The Patriot solidified his reputation as a talented actor and filmmaker.”

Gibson navigates the depths of “The Patriot” not only as the lead movie star but also as the director. His performance is nothing short of absolutely captivating and emotionally-charging. As a “former war hero, Benjamin Martin’s peaceful life is turned upside down when violent conflicts erupt between colonists and the British army,” starts Ultimate Action Movies. Then, after witnessing “the brutality of a British regiment he digs up his old weapon stash” and “the war and path for revenge is on!”

3. “We Were Soldiers” (2002)

Honoring the bravery and sacrifices of our soldiers, “We Were Soldiers” is a gripping war drama that showcases Gibson’s remarkable ability to embody complex roles. Delivering a top-notch performance, this tale is not for the faint of heart as you stroll across the battlefield. As Looper puts it, “Mel Gibson's portrayal of Lt. Col. Hal Moore is indisputably the finest of his career.” How does he master this performance? By perfecting the art of portraying a “quietly authoritative soldier with an unquestioning allegiance to God, his country, and his men.” 

The Vietnam War is one of the darkest blemishes of American history. From the opening scene to the rolling credits, “We Were Soldiers” is a tribute to the heroism and sacrifices of those in uniform. As Tech Preview recounts, “We Were Soldiers did really well in theaters, it was liked by all, and people really liked how Mel Gibson stood out as Lieutenant Colonel Hal Moore.” In addition, “other actors in the movie, like Sam Elliott and Barry Pepper, were also praised for their break-out performances.” For historical buffs out there, you’ll be pleased to learn We Were Soldiers “is based on a true story about the Battle of Ia Drang during the Vietnam War.”

Sit down, put your feet up, and watch Gibson do the rest. Conveying strength, vulnerability, and resilience, Mel Gibson’s acting in We Were Soldiers is unforgettable. As Chillopedia says, “The drama is based on a best-seller book by retired general Harold G. Moore.” And like all American war movies, it shows outnumbered forces in dire circumstances prevailing victorious.” With shreds of historical accuracy, this movie takes you through the “first great land battle between American and North Vietnamese troops in 1965.”

4. “Lethal Weapon” (1987)

Meet Martin Riggs, an unconventional police detective with a dodgy past portrayed by Mel Gibson. Released in 1987, this film solidified Gibson’s position as a bona fide action hero. As explained by Tech Preview, “Lethal Weapon is a famous movie that played a significant part in creating the buddy cop genre...It also made Mel Gibson a well-known actor in Hollywood” while what makes the movie memorable would be its “mix of action, comedy, and heartfelt moments.” 

Between the 1980s and 1990s, “Lethal Weapon” grew into an action franchise staple. With co-star Danny Glover, Gibson put on a heart-pounding performance that brilliantly displays his comedic brilliance. As Gold Derby recalls, “The success of Lethal Weapon launched Gibson’s most financially lucrative franchise with a bang.” Receiving significant praise, Lethal Weapon brings together “an effective mix of comedy and action in the witty script by Shane Black.”

The first of many successful sequels, “Lethal Weapon” is one of Mel Gibson’s best movies. From his magnetic screen presence to the relatable protagonist plot, this adrenaline-filled movie is a fan favorite for good reason. And “for all hardcore action fans out there, this movie is highly recommended,” claims Chillopedia. With a simple enough storyline, this film follows “two unorthodox cops that are paired together to bust a drug-smuggling gang.” Directed by Richard Donner, “Lethal Weapon has an Academy Award nomination for Best Sound.”

5. “Signs” (2002)

“Signs” is a gripping and atmospheric science fiction thriller that couples family, faith, and fear of the unknown. With supernatural and emotional elements, Signs stands as one of Gibson’s most iconic thrillers. As Gold Derby depicts, “Signs does an incredible job selling the audience and playing the hero.” Upon sightings of an alien creature, Mel is led to “believe that a full-scale extra-terrestrial invasion is about to take place.” 

Imagine waking up and looking out your window to see strange circles in your crops. Well, that’s how the stage kicks off for Mel Gibson as Graham Hess, a former priest who had a falling out with faith. As explained by Chillopedia, “The plot begins with the simple appearance of crop circles and an underlying ominous feeling.” Next, Shyamalan uses “simple everyday acts with a hint of the supernatural” to keep viewers on the edge of their seats. 

Directed by M. Night Shyamalan, Signs is deeply thought-provoking and goes beyond the grain of a typical science fiction thriller. As the story unfolds, Gibson’s performance anchors the film and makes you contemplate the questions surrounding faith and destiny. To sum it up, “this movie is about crop circles, hostile aliens, grief, survival, existentialism, and faith,” writes Movie Web. More so, “Gibson gives a solid and convincing performance, ranging from vulnerability, doubt, and self-contemplation, to calm yet authoritative protectiveness when his family is attacked by aliens.” Thanks to Gibson’s performance, the “level of intensity with his character was heightened and believable.” 

Sources used to create our lists: 

• Looper
• BuddyTV
• Movie Web
• Gold Derby
• Chillopedia
• Film Lifestyle
• Tech Preview
• Ninja Selection
• Wealth of Geeks
• Ultimate Action Movies

Note: This article was not paid for nor sponsored. EdNews is not connected to nor partnered with any of the brands mentioned and receives no compensation for its recommendations. This article may contain affiliate links in which we receive a commission if you make a purchase.